2010
Best Actress (Drama), Small Theater
Anne Gottlieb, Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune
Best Choreography, Small Theater
Kelli Edwards, Hot Mikado
2009
Best Actor (Drama), Small Theater
Robert Pemberton, Speed-the-Plow
Best Supporting Actor (Drama), Small Theater
Gabriel Kuttner, Speed-the-Plow
2008
Best New Play, Small Theater
According to Tip
Best Lighting Design, Small Theater
Karen Perlow, The Lieutenant of Inishmore
Best Solo Performance, Small Theater
Ken Howard, According to Tip
Best Supporting Actor (Drama), Small Theater
Karl Baker Olson, The Lieutenant of Inishmore
2007
Best Set Design, Small Theater
Janie E. Howland, A Streetcar Named Desire
Best Sound, Small Theater
Haddon Kime, A Streetcar Named Desire
Best Ensemble, Small Theater
The Wild Party
Supporting Actor (Drama), Small Theater
Bates Wilder, A Streetcar Named Desire
Best Actress (Drama), Small Theater
Rachel Harker, A Streetcar Named Desire
Supporting Actress (Musical), Small Theater
Sarah Corey, The Wild Party
Best Director (Drama), Small Theater
Rick Lombardo, A Streetcar Named Desire
Best Drama, Small Theater
A Streetcar Named Desire
2006
Best Actor (Drama or Comedy), Small Theater
Bates Wilder, Frozen
Best Music Director of a Musical, Small Theater
Todd C. Gordon, Ragtime
Best Director of a Musical, Small Theater
Rick Lombardo, Ragtime
Best Musical, Small Theater
Ragtime
2005
Best Actor in a Play, Small Theater
Todd Alan Johnson, True West, and Joe Wilson, Jr., Topdog/Underdog
Best Set Design, Small Theater
Eugene Lee, Topdog/Underdog
Best Supporting Actor in a Musical, Small Theater
Todd Alan Johnson, Into the Woods
Best Supporting Actress in a Musical, Small Theater
Veronica J. Kuehn, Into the Woods
Best Actress in a Musical, Small Theater
Leigh Barrett, Into the Woods
Best Music Director, Small Theater
Todd Gordon, Into the Woods
Best Costume Design, Small Theater
Nancy Leary, Into the Woods
2003
Best Production—Musical, Small Theater
Sweeney Todd
Best Production—Drama, Small Theater
Waiting for Godot
Best Actress—Musical, Small Theater
Nancy E. Carroll, Sweeney Todd
Best Supporting Actress—Drama, Small Theater
Bobbie Steinbach, A Girl’s War
Best Supporting Actress—Musical, Small Theater
Leigh Barrett, Sweeney Todd
Best Director—Musical, Small Theater
Rick Lombardo, Sweeney Todd
Best Musical Direction, Small Theater
Janet Roma, Sweeney Todd
Best Lighting Design, Small Theater
Franklin Meissner, Jr., Sweeney Todd
Best Sound Design, Small Theater
Haddon Kime, A Girl’s War
Best Costume Design, Small Theater
Frances Nelson McSherry and Christine Alger, Sweeney Todd
2002
Best Costume Design, Small Theater
Emily Dunn, Tartuffe
2001
Best Drama, Small Theater
The Weir
Best Ensemble, Small Theater
The Weir
Best Supporting Actor, Small Theater
Billy Meleady, The Weir
Best Solo, Small Theater
Lucille Patton, Rose
Best Scenic Design, Small Theater
Kristen Loeffler, Moby Dick, an American Opera
Best Lighting Design, Small Theater
Franklin Meissner, Jr., Moby Dick, an American Opera